Monday, January 29, 2007

A flawed food system

One would assume -- given the essential and undisputed role food plays in our lives -- that attaining a sustainable, healthy food system would be at the top of the list of priorities of every nation. However, if you were an alien hovering above Earth in your spacecraft observing the general state of agriculture throughout the world, it would be difficult to convince yourself that food is a basic human need. Sensible, sustainable food production suffers under the pressure to maximize profits by squeezing as much out of the system as possible in a chemically and/or genetically-influenced accelerated time frame, utilizing as little space possible.

It has been twenty years since the publication of "Our Common Future". That report of the World Commission on Environment and Development is credited with coining the term "sustainable development". I have frequent debates with friends and colleagues who argue that the concept of sustainable development doesn't serve a useful purpose because it is too ambiguous and difficult to translate into practice. It's interesting that few make the same argument with regard to sustainable agriculture. That movement has managed to define itself in theory and in practice.

Nova Scotia's experience described below is a case study in unsustainable agriculture. Look for examples of sustainable farming practices/systems in future posts. (GW)


Poultry plant closure: cracks in a flawed food system

SUDDENLY, a crisis in agriculture: 380 jobs down the chute as the Maple Leaf Foods poultry plant closes in Canard. Hog farmers on the brink too, and Maple Leaf’s meat-packing plant in Berwick also in question. Is there more to come?

In Nova Scotia and elsewhere, the figures have accelerated recently on their decades-long trend: farm incomes sharply down and farm debt sharply up, while the handful of huge corporations that control the system get more and more profitable.

These tremours in what remains of Nova Scotia agriculture are symptomatic of deep and worldwide fault lines. You may have noticed, especially since the mad cow disease crisis of a few years ago, more and more stories about the sinister side of food: E. coli in the broccoli, a rash of peculiar cancers in the P.E.I. potato fields, the obesity epidemic, tropical forests razed for cattle and soybeans, loss of biodiversity, genetic meddling, fears about terrorists hitting over-centralized food systems, and so on.

These are the echoes of a deeper rumble that I expect to come to the forefront of the news within the year. It has to do with outing the perverse and unsustainable food system that has evolved over the past 40 years – the same one that stocks your supermarket shelves so beautifully, at a price you usually can afford, but the workings of which agribusiness expects you to stay dutifully ignorant lest you get queasy.

Consider elements of a recent report from the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, which the New York Times called "striking and alarming." It said that livestock is responsible for 18 per cent of the global warming effect – more than transportation’s contribution. Could we of the First World, notorious for the enormity of our consumption, be eating – and wasting – too much meat?

Or consider this effect: Manure, which should be the prime ingredient of sustainable agriculture, has been turned into a pollutant by concentrated megafarms. Or the new strains of E. coli which have apparently evolved in feedlots, where cattle puddle their lives away in their own manure. It goes on. In short, now that we appear to have got serious about the environment, it follows that we’ll have to do the same with one of its main ingredients, the food system.

And not just with regard to production, but to its next step: transportation. According to the Washington-based Worldwatch Institute, the average food item in the U.S. travels 2,500 to 4,000 kilometres before it gets to the table. In Nova Scotia, on the fringes, it could be more than that. As in most other places, where we produced about 80 per cent of our food some 50 years ago, now it’s the reverse – we import about 80 per cent.

In terms of twisted effects, there’s also the consumption part. Some 30 years of advertising to kids by junk-food conglomerates has led to what is being called an epidemic of obesity and early-onset diabetes. Here I have to give the Rodney MacDonald government a rare pat on the back for its law banning junk food from the province’s school cafeterias. I’m surprised the manufacturers haven’t put on the usual propaganda campaign. Maybe they’re embarrassed. This is a good sign.

As for our Nova Scotia crisis: Alas, from an immediate public policy point of view, the option at hand is mostly to subsidize or not to subsidize. The hog farmers have already been extended $10 million and obviously there’s a limit. As for the poultry plant, if Maple Leaf wants to consolidate in Ontario, there’s not a lot the government can do. Bribing it to stay would not be good policy either, although getting the rival ACA co-operative to pick up the slack might bring some relief.

So the only option in the short term is mostly to try to cushion the blow. In the long term, however, the system of control by a few agricultural behemoths must be broken in favour of local agriculture. This will require some new thinking. Some people are at it now. Reading my current copy of the Coastal Community News, the New Glasgow-based magazine of rural Nova Scotia, I found a report on a recent international conference in Vancouver hosted by the Food Secure Canada coalition, in which healthy and safe food, a sustainable food system and zero hunger were proclaimed as goals.

I was interested to learn that, along with several other Nova Scotians, it was attended by a representative of the Nova Scotia Department of Agriculture, Jamey Couglin, who was quoted as saying: "It was really inspiring to see the diverse and creative partnerships using food to promote sustainability, health and wellness, social justice, economic development and livable communities." The article described Nova Scotia as "an emerging leader in the national movement" which is "leading the way" with its school nutrition policy.

So maybe we have something to work with here. Keep an eye on this issue. It’s big. I’ll be back to it myself.

Ralph Surette is a veteran freelance journalist living in Yarmouth County.

4 Comments:

Blogger Damanick said...

Hey. Nice blog... I stumbled upon this article today, and its very good. Yup, we are in a food crisis. I also posted this on my blog streetblabber.blogspot.com Check it out! Good Luck

6:10 PM  
Blogger Kelly Chen said...

GHD straighteners
abercrombie and fitch
beats headphones
french blue 7s
nike dunk shoes
GHD hair straighteners
abercrombie & fitch outlet
beats by dre
michael kors
Giuseppe Zanotti shoes
jimmy choo
louboutin shoes
christian louboutin shoes
Mont Blanc pens
toms shoes
air max
air jordan 11
michael kors
coach bags
air jordans
jordan 4 columbia blue
legend blue 4s
coach bags
beats by dr dre
michael kors
kobe 9 elite
air jordan 11
air jordan 29
herve leger
christian louboutin sale
air jordan 29
air jordan 11
air jordan 11
jordan 11
air jordan 11
retro jordan 11
jordan 6 shoes
herve leger dresses
replica ugs
fake uggs
jordan 11 legend blue
gucci belts
infrared 6s 2014
fake ugg boots
data lebron 12
nike lebron 12 data
kobe 9 elite
kobe 9 elite christmas

9:24 AM  
Blogger Kelly Chen said...

nike kobe 9 elites
kobe 9 elite
jimmy choo shoes
Giuseppe Zanotti shoes
Giuseppe Zanotti shoes
herve leger dresses
jimmy choo
designer shoes
gucci belts
gucci belts
legend blue 11s
jordan 11 legend blue
jordan 11 legend blue
retro 11 legend blue
legend blues
air jordan 11 legend blue
jordan 11 legend blue
retro 11 legend blue
jordan 11 legend blue
legend blue 11s
gamma blue 11s
black infrared 6s
black infrared 6s
black infrared 6s 2014
pre order jordans
jordan 6 black infrared
jordan 11 legend blue
jordan 6 black infrared
jordan 6 black infrared
air jordan 11 legend blue
air jordan 11 legend blue
jordan legend 11s
legend blue 11s
air jordan 11 legend blue
air jordan 6 black infrared
retro legend blue 11
legend blue 11s
legend blue 11s
legend blue 11s
legend blue 11s
legend blue 11s
black infrared 6s
black infrared 6s
jordan 13 grey toe
grey toe 13s
grey toe 13s
cheap designer shoes
designer shoes

9:26 AM  
Blogger Kelly Chen said...

designer shoes
jimmy choo shoes
jimmy choo shoes
jimmy choo
red bottoms
new balance
new balance outlet
herve leger dresses
herve leger dresses
herve leger outlet
bodycon dresses
bodycon dresses
bodycon dresses
bandage dresses
jimmy choo outlet
bandage dresses
cheap gucci belts
new balance
Giuseppe Zanotti
air jordan 13 retro premium
air jordan 3M reflective
christian louboutin so kate
cheap air max
nike free run
red bottoms
sport blue 6s
air jordan 11
jordan infrared 23
legend blue 11s
Giuseppe Zanotti shoes
jimmy choo sale
jimmy choo shoes

9:27 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home